Should You Choose Different Hardwood for Upstairs vs. Downstairs?

When planning your hardwood flooring project, one question many homeowners face is whether to select different hardwood options for rooms upstairs versus downstairs. At Corlew and Perry, we’ve been helping homeowners in Franklin, Brentwood, and Nashville, TN, make confident flooring decisions since 1927. Let’s explore whether you should choose uniform hardwood for your entire home or consider variations based on the unique needs of different levels.

The case for consistency

Choosing the same hardwood flooring throughout your home creates a seamless and cohesive look. Here are the main benefits of this approach:

1. A unified aesthetic

Using the same hardwood upstairs and downstairs provides visual flow and continuity. This is particularly important in open-concept homes where flooring transitions between spaces are more visible.

2. Easier resale appeal

Potential buyers often appreciate a consistent design. Uniform hardwood flooring can enhance the perceived value of your home by creating a polished and well-thought-out look.

3. Streamlined maintenance

With the same type of hardwood throughout, you’ll have fewer cleaning products and maintenance protocols to juggle. A single finish simplifies the process of refinishing in the future.

When differences make sense

While consistency has its advantages, there are practical and stylistic reasons to choose different hardwoods for upstairs and downstairs.

1. Sound control considerations

Hardwood floors can amplify sound, making noise travel easily between floors. For upstairs areas, consider using engineered hardwood with a sound-dampening underlayment to minimize footsteps and echoes.

2. Traffic and durability needs

High-traffic areas like living rooms and kitchens on the main level may benefit from more durable wood species, such as oak or hickory. Bedrooms upstairs might allow for softer woods, like cherry or walnut, which prioritize elegance over resilience.

3. Style variations for function

Different floors can reflect the function of each level. For instance, the main level could feature a statement-making wide-plank floor, while the upstairs rooms might have narrower planks for a cozier feel.

4. Budget considerations

Downstairs floors are often seen more by visitors, so homeowners might allocate a higher budget to premium hardwood in these areas. Upstairs, where the floors are primarily for family use, more cost-effective options may suffice without compromising quality.

Hardwood trends for multi-level homes

At Corlew and Perry, we’ve noticed a few trends when it comes to hardwood in multi-level homes:

1. Mixing finishes

Some homeowners choose the same wood species but use different finishes upstairs and downstairs. For example, a natural finish downstairs for a rustic look and a darker stain upstairs for a more formal vibe.

2. Transition strips for style

If you decide on different hardwoods, transition strips can create a smooth visual change between floors. These strips can also protect the edges of your flooring, reducing wear and tear.

3. Sustainability in design

Eco-conscious customers often opt for engineered hardwood upstairs due to its lower environmental impact, paired with solid hardwood downstairs for a luxurious touch.

Factors to discuss with your flooring expert

If you’re unsure whether to keep your hardwood consistent or vary it between levels, consider these factors:

Home layout: Does your home have a clear division between upstairs and downstairs, or are they easily visible to one another?
Lifestyle needs: Do you have children, pets, or frequent gatherings that could affect durability needs?
Acoustic concerns: Is sound traveling between floors a potential issue for your household?
Budget: How much are you willing to invest in each level of your home?

Why choose Corlew and Perry?

Since 1927, Corlew and Perry has been Franklin’s trusted source for premier hardwood flooring. Serving Brentwood and Nashville, we take pride in offering personalized service, premium materials, and expert advice. Whether you’re envisioning a unified hardwood look or a creative mix, our team can guide you through every step of the decision-making process.

Visit our showroom in Franklin, TN

Choosing the perfect hardwood for your home is easier with hands-on experience. Visit our showroom in Franklin, TN, to explore a wide range of options. Whether you’re in Brentwood, Nashville, or beyond, let Corlew and Perry help you achieve a stunning result that complements your home’s style and function.